My daughter weaned at 3 1/2 years. In retrospect, it was a stressful time for us and she’d developed a lazy latch which hurt me, so I probably discouraged nursing more than it being a true case of self-weaning. If I’d corrected the latch, we may have kept on nursing.
Here’s the thing – she’s 7 now and still remembers nursing. She’s asked to nurse
over the last couple of years and I’ve had to explain there’s nothing left. I’ve just found out I’m pregnant again, to my fiance – not her father, who I split from when she was 18 months old. She’s asked if she can nurse when I have milk again. I have no problem with it – honestly, she may read at a 12-year-old level, she may fly by herself and make her own lunches, but if she wants to nurse she’s still my baby and it seems like the most natural thing in the world to me. My fiance, a first time dad, feels similarly. He was the first one to ask “I wonder if A will want to nurse when the baby gets here?”
The problem here is, I can see it being met with a LOT of hostility if it gets back to her father and specifically her stepmother. Apparently she was rebuked for calling the large spiked rubber ball she was playing with on the deck a ‘nipple ball’ – they’ve always been ‘nipple balls’ to her since she suckled on one as a hungry baby. Nipples aren’t shameful body parts to us. But, it’s because of this that I didn’t give her a clear answer.
For me, I see no logical grounds other than what I’ve described to deny her. Anthropologist Katherine Dettwyler puts the natural age of human weaning at somewhere between 4.5 and 7 years, but really, no one knows. It doesn’t suddenly become ‘wrong’, that’s for sure. The reasons not to are all based on dated ideas of what is ‘proper’, ideas which I’ve long since shrugged off when it comes to other issues. It could also a) help me with engorgement and building a good supply and b) soothe jealousy issues with a child who’s never had to deal with a sibling before. Chances are, she’d try it once, latch badly with her mouthful of (some) adult teeth and give up.
When she was a newborn, I once ignorantly expressed my horror at breastfeeding a school-aged child when someone talked of nursing a five-year-old. Having no comprehension of what toddler nursing was like, I imagined Mom having to come to school and lift her shirt in front of all Little Johnny’s friends. I now know that’s BS – I’ve nursed a toddler on a bed in the ER, wearing work boots and sporting a broken hand. Nursing’s flexible. I thought people who would nurse a six-year-old must be crazy hippies – then I met some in the flesh. One was an intelligent and educated artist who wore decidedly sensible and non-tie-dyed clothing; the other was conservative by nature and owned a couple of businesses.
So – what do I say to my daughter? I’ve been non-committal so far. I have tried to explain, gently, that while I feel that there can never be anything wrong with a mother feeding her baby (mine still plies me with chocolate brownies, after all) that not everyone will agree with that – that some people will think that nursing a 7-year-old is plain wrong. I also don’t want to blur the lines of good secret and bad if we decide to let her, but advise discretion.